Category Archives: Simply Put
By Mike Whittlesey
Last week, more than 90 veterans from eastern and central Iowa were aboard the 15th Honor Flight sponsored by Sullivan-Hartogh-Davis Post 730 in Waterloo. The Progress Review has been fortunate to have a photographer along for the ride for 13 of those flights, as part of our commitment to provide each veteran with a commemorative DVD documenting their experience in Washington DC. Last week’s trip marked the first opportunity for Waterloo area veterans of the Vietnam War to make an Honor Flight, and more than 60 of the 90+ veterans aboard the flight served their country during that conflict.
Prior to the flight, I wondered if this first trip with Vietnam veterans to Washington would make for a different Honor Flight experience. It most certainly did, and in a way that was far more powerful than I could have imagined.
The challenge of shooting photos and video on the journey from Waterloo to Washington DC and back makes for a very busy day. That’s what makes the time spent in the air so enjoyable. The two hour flight provides an excellent opportunity to meet and visit with some of the veterans, always an educational experience when they describe their time in the military.
On this trip, I sat next to a veteran who spoke about serving on an LST (Landing Ship, Tank), a ship designed to support amphibious operations by carrying vehicles, cargo, and landing troops directly onto an unimproved shore. While serving in Vietnam, he described an incredibly harrowing experience, a sneak attack carried out by the enemy that claimed the lives of seventeen of his shipmates.
Researching the incident, I learned that at 3:22 AM on November 1, 1968, two large mines were detonated on the starboard side of the U.S.S. Westchester County (LST-1167). Boiler Technician Gary Wood, from Decorah, Iowa, was one of the lucky crew members who survived the initial attack. In the moments after the blast, his responsibility was to seal a door below deck to help prevent the ship from sinking.
Chest deep in water and oil, Gary knew that sealing the door would more than likely also seal the fate of anyone still alive in that compartment, a thought, he said, he has had to live with since that fateful day.
Forty-eight years later, as he prepared to visit the Vietnam War Memorial for the first time, Gary Wood carried with him a small piece of paper upon which he had written several names.
“These are my guys!” he told me.
A unique feature about the Vietnam War Memorial is that the names inscribed upon the wall are listed chronologically, so that those who served and died together will forever be memorialized together on the black granite. Gary’s search for his brothers, the shipmates who lost their lives while serving their country nearly 50 years ago, would take him to panels 39 and 40 of the west wall. Among the names listed there were the following U.S. Navy sailors:
Jackie C Carter, Richard C Cartwright, Chester D Dale, Keith William Duffy, Timothy C Dunning, David G Fell, Thomas G Funke, Gerald E B Hamm, Floyd Houghtaling III, Aristotoles D Ibanez, Jerry S Leonard, Joesph A Miller Jr, Rodney W Peters, Cary F Rundle, Reinhard J Schnurrer Jr, Thomas H Smith, Anthony R Torcivia
Gary would later admit to getting emotional at that moment. Who could blame him? Standing there with a camera in my hand, it didn’t feel right to point it in his direction, as this very personal moment played out among the hundreds of people who were milling about. Looking up and down along the 246 feet of polished granite, Gary was not alone in his emotion. Tears were evident as other veterans, family members and friends located the names for whom they searched. Some stood quietly, while others kneeled at the wall, deep in prayer.
The Vietnam War Memorial Wall was constructed in 1982 in an effort to heal the scars, still evident today, that this controversial war left behind. Standing there in the bright sunshine on a beautiful day in the nation’s capital, I was reminded why the Honor Flight program is so beneficial for the veterans who make the trip to Washington DC. It’s a journey that is perhaps even more important for our Vietnam War veterans, the men and women who did not receive the homecoming they deserved for their service to the nation.
Finally, as I ascended the walkway to return to our tour bus, I couldn’t help but think how glad Gary’s guys must have been that he stopped by to pay them a visit.
Did you know it takes more than $100,000 to make one Honor Flight from Waterloo to Washington DC? For more information about upcoming flights, how to apply as a volunteer, guardian or veteran, or how you can donate or assist the Honor Flight organization, logon to www.CedarValleyHonorFlights.org send an email to: firstname.lastname@example.org
The book serves as a vivid illustration that just as we are changed by events that mold and shape us, so too are the places we call home. The phrase “You can’t go home again” has come to symbolize that, as much as we may want, we cannot relive a life of the past.
Thirty years ago, Neil Mullen made a return to his home town. And the students he has served since in the Union Community School District are better because of it. A 1976 La Porte City High School graduate, Neil attended Wartburg College after graduation. After earning his degree, he then taught Business Education and Physical Education for five years at the North Mahaska School District.
In 1986, he returned home to La Porte City. And for the next 30 years, he proceeded to do a little bit of everything in the world of K-12 education, starting as a Physical Education teacher at La Porte City Elementary School. In 1989, when the communities of La Porte City and Dysart were in the early stages of merging, Neil was hired to succeed George Kelley as Principal of Union High School. He was 31 years old at the time.
Six years later, he subsequently made the transition to Principal at Dysart-Geneseo Elementary School when Joe Coffey retired. In 2005, when the Union Community School Board was looking for a Superintendent, they didn’t have to look far to find someone imminently qualified.
During Neil’s eleven year tenure as Superintendent, the Union Community School District has continued to evolve with the times. The move to more secure school facilities in a post 9/11 world, state-of-art improvements to the athletic and fine arts facilities at Union High School and the successful transition to tuition-free preschool for the district’s four year olds are just a few of the significant changes that have taken place under his leadership.
For someone who wasn’t supposed to go home again, Neil Mullen has spent the last 30 years serving his home town in a variety of roles- teacher, principal and superintendent. Having had the pleasure of working with him for three of those years, it is easy to see why he has been described as an “exceptional education leader.” At meetings, Neil listened carefully, and his words, when spoken, were usually brief and always on point. When it came to debating difficult issues, Neil’s was the voice of common sense that cut through superfluous details to the heart of the matter. And his sense of humor could add a moment of levity at just the right time.
Such was the case several years ago at a home football game on a Friday night. Prior to the start of the varsity game, with many of the elementary and middle school youngsters we were being asked to “supervise” engaged in a variety of activities that could gently be described as horseplay, I was impressed with how calm Neil semed to be, given the amount of activity around us. As I sidled up to him along the fence that surrounded the football field, eager to learn his thoughts on how to bring order to chaos, he shared his inspiration. It came, I was surprised to discover, in the form of lyrics. Quietly, he began to sing, only needing the first line of Carl Douglass’ 1974 hit to make his point: “Everybody was kung fu fighting…”
On July 1, Neil Mullen will pass the torch to his successor, current Union High School Principal, Travis Fleshner, an outstanding educator in his own right. The two have worked closely since Mr. Fleshner arrived at the high school in 2005. While there will no doubt be challenges ahead, patrons of the Union Community School District have every reason to expect their children will continue to be afforded an opportunity to receive an excellent education.
But before the 2015-16 school year comes to a close, there are just a few words that need to be said to the retiring superintendent:
“Thanks for coming home, Neil.”
By Mike Whittlesey
Are the good people of La Porte City unknowingly killing their community? Before we dismiss such thoughts as utter nonsense, perhaps a close inspection of the book with a provocative title, 13 Ways to Kill Your Community is in order. The book’s author, Doug Griffiths, grew up in a small town in Alberta, Canada and was an award-winning teacher before seeking office as a Member of the Legislative Assembly in the Province of Alberta, where he served for four consecutive terms and gained the reputation as a passionate advocate for building strong communities. Last year, he retired from politics to form a company that develops practical tools communities and organizations can use to assess and identify the challenges threatening their growth, along with strategies that can help turn those challenges into opportunities for success.
The book Thirteen Ways to Kill Your Community came about as a result of Griffiths’ extensive work with rural communities, particularly those working hard to find ways ensure a vibrant and prosperous future. While individuals, governmental bodies and the communities they represent certainly do not carry with them an overt desire to harm or damage their own community, the author speaks to the attitudes, beliefs and actions that are sometimes taken for short-term gain that ultimately hurt, not help, the places where they live.
Want to kill your community? Try Chapter 2, entitled “Don’t Attract Business.”
“Shop local” is a phrase often heard in smaller communities like La Porte City. Because so many residents in our community work in the Waterloo-Cedar Falls metropolitan area, much of their purchasing power goes with them when they travel north on U.S. Hwy. 218. What can the locals find there that isn’t always present in their home town? In many cases, it’s competition, the engine that drives free enterprise. Competition offers consumers choices when it comes to price, quality, selection and service. In a small town, a limited number of retail opportunities can make competition hard to find. After many, many years in La Porte City, for example, the closing of the Pronto Market leaves Casey’s as the only convenience store in town.
For students of economics, the value of competition is not a new revelation. Unfortunately, its value is sometimes lost in smaller communities. In the context where local shopkeepers are neighbors and friends with members of the governing body that determines whether new businesses are welcomed or turned away, economic decisions can become more difficult to make. Last summer in La Porte City, the proposed construction of a Dollar General Store on the north edge of town was initially declined before the City Council reconsidered the project’s value in terms of property tax revenue, new jobs and retail sales dollars invested in the community. Will the new store become competition for existing businesses? Most definitely. Fortunately for La Porte City residents, history has shown that such competition will give area residents improved selection when it comes to prices, quality, variety of merchandise and service. Savvy business owners understand that every dollar entering the community gets passed around town several times. The dollars spent in Waterloo and Cedar Falls? Gone. And not likely to find their way back to La Porte City where they could have exchanged hands at local businesses several times over.
The lessons taught in the chapter “Don’t Attract Business” can be applied beyond the obvious Main Street merchants. Last fall, a structural failure of the bridge spanning Wolf Creek in La Porte City interrupted the continuous path of the 46 mile long Cedar Valley Nature Trail (CVNT). Replacing the bridge will cost millions of dollars, money neither Black Hawk County Conservation nor the City of La Porte City has, or will have, in the near future. As officials and government leaders explore options to restore traffic so that the trail can, once again, travel unimpeded through our community, detour signs for cyclists who use the trail will soon be posted along the route. The detour will encourage riders to leave the trail in Gilbertville and proceed south to La Porte City via Canfield Road. The reality is that many recreational riders will opt to skip the detour altogether and simply turn around and go back from where they came. For local eateries and other La Porte City businesses that cater to CVNT users, a detour that bypasses the community is a lost opportunity (and revenue).
Is the traffic that passes through town on the Cedar Valley Nature Trail important to La Porte City? Are there economic benefits for our community that should be considered if the City Council is called upon to make decisions regarding this issue?
Communities that thrive, Griffiths notes, are the ones where people come together and seek solutions for the greater good. Consider an issue confronted by our community nearly 40 years ago when, for a brief time, La Porte City was without a physician. Because of the concerted effort organized by a number of area residents working together, medical care and pharmacy services were restored to the citizens of La Porte City. Where would our community be today without them?
When it comes to attracting businesses to La Porte City, we shouldn’t wait for a similar crisis to get started.
By Mike Whittlesey
The following column is written in response to a letter to the editor from Justin Murphy. Read the letter here.
In a world where social media makes it easy to voice personal opinions in a public forum, signing one’s name to a letter to the editor takes conviction. Mr. Murphy should be commended for his fortitude.
As the Editor in Chief, I am ultimately responsible for everything that appears in the print, online and digital editions of The Progress Review. When we purchased La Porte City’s newspaper in 2002, we made a commitment to the community to continue producing a weekly newspaper that dates back to the 1870s.
As Mr. Murphy noted, readers looking for scandals are not likely to find them in the pages of The Progress Review. If publishing the “negative happenings” in our community was a priority, it would be worth my time to investigate rumors circulating around town. But it is not. There are several reasons why.
Every printed page in The Progress Review comes with a cost. That is why, on average, 40% of the content we publish each week is devoted to advertising. Advertisers make it possible to keep the subscription price our readers pay lower than many other weekly newspapers in the state. Consequently, my job as editor is to publish the news and feature stories I believe our readers will find informative and meaningful, given the limited space available.
While I have certainly heard a number of rumors circulating around town during my tenure at The Progress Review, I must admit that I definitely do not make an effort to “keep up-to-date with rumors spreading around like wild fires.” At The Progress Review, before any article gets investigated or written, a simple question helps determine its worthiness for publication: What is the value of the story?
In the case of the suspension of Union High School football players, it is their status as juveniles that helps keep their names from being made public in this newspaper. In many cases, law enforcement officials and school district administrators are not obligated to release the names of juveniles to the media, out of deference to their juvenile status. Investigating such rumors is a moot point if the names of the students in question are not willingly made available to the media.
In response to other examples cited in Mr. Murphy’s letter, what value does a “town alcoholic” story have to offer the community? How about an “abusive husband” story? What is the merit to publishing a story about an alleged “student-teacher scandal”? In each of these examples, no investigation conducted by The Progress Review is likely to advance the story beyond its rumor status. Publishing unsubstantiated rumors is akin to action “that is defamatory or that maliciously or damagingly misrepresents.” In other words, libel. Our readers deserve better than that. That is also why the names of specific individuals referenced in Mr. Murphy’s letter were redacted prior to publication.
Over the past 14 years, there are numerous reports of “negative happenings” to be found in the pages of The Progress Review. The police reports and law enforcement press releases we do publish have what the aforementioned “scandals” lack- an event that takes place resulting in the accused being formally charged with a crime. It is not The Progress Review’s job to report accusations based on rumor or innuendo. Would such stories sell more papers? Perhaps. We choose to leave investigations of possible misdeeds to the agencies who are far better equipped to conduct them properly.
In 2016, the number of family-owned newspapers in the United States continues to decline. As publishers of La Porte City’s hometown newspaper, we are afforded the opportunity to share the stories about the people and events in our community like no other media outlet. It’s a responsibility we take very seriously, the reason we continue to look for ways to improve our community, not tear it down. It’s also the reason why, after 14 years, The Progress Review’s commitment to our home town remains as strong as ever. –MW